« Coulter Rides Again | Main | Getting bin Laden & Jugurtha »

September 11, 2006

Comments

scott edwards

While I laud you on your ambitious summer reading, includung an aquaintence of mine Ms Paglia- who did it her way at Yale, I am left wondering at your conclusion regarding Eddie Gibbons "Decline & Fall" and the islamic swarm into Spain created by a power vaccum in Rome's decline.
(I am not the first to point out that Gibbons masterpiece is hardly the last word being published some 125 yrs ago.. and the various Book Of The Month Clubs will offer the nine volumes gratis if you'll kindly sign up to receive their next eight monthy choises and etc...) I'll wager that none of your august readership has waded through Gibbons and maybe a few have heard of it via the bookclub offers. However, Gibbons has emphatically stated that the decline can be mainly attributed to the reduction of the Roman senate to a mere appendage of Ceaser and the debauchery of the citizenry increased expoentially with the consolidation of power in the emporer and the maldistribution of the wealth created from the spoils of war. When Gringoman instructs his unwashed on "Rome becoming too smart for its gods" he means that the Ceasers in their quest of a unitary executive no longer felt bound by the legal and ethical constraints imposed by the religion or the senate. The unravelling of Rome started at the top; though sometimes in these multi-volume tomes it is hard to see the public hot baths from the vomitorium.

Scott edwards

Apropos your rendition of the Tower above, I am reminded of Parson Weems who it seems had a penchant for conflating into an imbroglio christian religion with the american flag at the founding of the new republic. Weems had a senior moment when it came to the seperation clause of the american constitution and spun tales regarding Washington in particular, some of which survive to this day. (See Weems, Washington and the Cherry Tree) Whilst Parson Weems had placed an imaginary hatchet in Washingtons hand, I thought it fitting that Gringoman do likewise with Washingtons penultimate sucessor; and in the context of the tower above. The parson after all had displayed some rather fascist tendencies, and one of them being that religon serve the state. I would allow Bush to mouth the same words

gringoman

I am left wondering at your conclusion regarding Eddie Gibbons "Decline & Fall" and the islamic swarm into Spain created by a power vaccum in Rome's decline.
(I am not the first to point out that Gibbons masterpiece is hardly the last word being published some 125 yrs ago.. and the various Book Of The Month Clubs will offer the nine volumes gratis if you'll kindly sign up to receive their next eight monthy choises and etc...) I'll wager that none of your august readership has waded through Gibbons and maybe a few have heard of it via the bookclub offers. However, Gibbons has emphatically stated that the decline can be mainly attributed to the reduction of the Roman senate to a mere appendage of Ceaser and the debauchery of the citizenry increased expoentially with the consolidation of power in the emporer and the maldistribution of the wealth created from the spoils of war. When Gringoman instructs his unwashed on "Rome becoming too smart for its gods" he means that the Ceasers in their quest of a unitary executive no longer felt bound by the legal and ethical constraints imposed by the religion or the senate. The unravelling of Rome started at the top; though sometimes in these multi-volume tomes it is hard to see the public hot baths from the vomitorium.
==============================

Wonder no more. Instead of the usual "progressive" interpretation of Gibbon, implying that Rome declined by becoming less "plebeian" or "democratic" or even "multy-culty" enough,(good old capital vs. labor strife?) try facing Gibbon head on, with or without Book Club bonuses. Of course some academmies can "correct" Gibbon here and there. Any monument can take a little polishing after 125 years, so let them wax away where they think they can. The stereotype argument that Rome deteriorated because the Senate surrendered to dictatorship seems to say everything while saying essentially nothing. Which makes it a favorite of....
Lighting a fire under a pot of water will heat the water, will it? Well, uh, yes, hey, you've got a point there. So forget about all the myriad of circumstances, who's lighting up, where, why, how etc etc. Just give us the simple-minded stuff about the "military" vs. the Senate and ignore what was happening to the composition of the Senate, the ruling families, the degradation of the Army and its once educated leadership etc. Still, if there's no time to look into the social realities, but you want to examine why the muslim fanatics now had a field day in storming out of their sand dunes and water holes and trampling over a once mighty civilization, there's still another option. You could quote Gibbon:

"The birth of Mohammed was fortunately placed in the most degenerate and disorderly period of the Persians, the Romans and the barbarians of Europe: the empires of Trajan, or even of Constantine or Charlemagne, would have repelled the assault of the naked Saracens, and the torrent of fanaticism might have been obscurely lost in the sands of Arabia."

hank aaron jersey discount


Great review and an interesting topic. Nice job! I will bookmark your site. I think you are right. .

UGG Boots Sale

I really feel like you may most likely teach a class on the best way to make a terrific weblog.http://www.replicaoakleycheap.com This really is great! I've to say, what truly got me was your style.http://www.topfakeoakleysunglasses.com You definitely know the best way to make your weblog far more than just a rant about an problem.http://www.sellmacmakeup.com Youve produced it achievable for individuals to connect.http://www.monclerjacketswholesaler.com/ Great for you, simply because not that a lot of people know what theyre undertaking.http://www.uggbootssalemall.com

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Site Seeing

  • Monicamemo
    Internet home of The Warrior Princess, Monica Crowley (the site also a gringoman hang-out.)
  • MilitaryCorruption.Com
    Fighting for the truth...Exposing the corrupt.
  • Atlas Shrugs
    Can a hottie save Western Civilization?
  • I Was a Liberal
    Female Therapist + 9.11=neo-neocon
  • The Filipina Firebrand
    Michelle Malkin, who else?

November 2012

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30  
Blog powered by Typepad